Compare water heaters side by side
Pick any two water heaters from the comparison pool to see their full specs head-to-head, with the annual-cost math done for you. Every model page also links to its most relevant comparisons. Comparisons stay within a category — heat pump vs gas is a guide question, not a spec table.
Heat pump water heaters
- AMERICAN STANDARD WATER HEATERS Heat Pump Water Heater 80-Gallon vs Rheem Heat Pump 80-Gallon (PROPH80 T2 RH375-30)
- AMERICAN STANDARD WATER HEATERS Heat Pump Water Heater 80-Gallon vs Rheem Heat Pump 80-Gallon (PROPH80 T2 RH400-30)
- Bosch heat pump water heater 65-Gallon vs Midea Water Heater 65-Gallon (CAN3-RSJ-15/250RDVN3-L4)
- Bosch heat pump water heater 65-Gallon vs Navien NWP500 65-Gallon
- Bosch Water heater 80-Gallon vs LG APHWC802D 80-Gallon
- Bosch Water heater 80-Gallon vs Midea Water Heater 80-Gallon (CAN3-RSJ-15/300RDVN3-L4)
- Bosch Water heater 80-Gallon vs Rinnai REHP80 80-Gallon
- Bradford White RE2HP50-1NCTT 40-Gallon vs Navien NWP500 40-Gallon
- Friedrich Heat Pump 40-Gallon (PROH40 T2 FD400-30) vs Richmond Heat Pump 40-Gallon (10E40-HP530)
- Friedrich Heat Pump 40-Gallon (PROH40 T2 FD400-30) vs Richmond Heat Pump 40-Gallon (10E40-HP5S30)
- Friedrich Heat Pump 65-Gallon (PROH65 T2 FD400-30) vs GE Profile Heat Pump 50-Gallon (PH50S10BNY01)
- Friedrich Heat Pump 65-Gallon (PROH65 T2 FD400-30) vs Rheem Heat Pump 65-Gallon (PROPH65 T2 RH375-30)
- GE Profile Heat Pump 50-Gallon (PH50S10BNY01) vs Rheem Heat Pump 65-Gallon (PROPH65 T2 RH375-30)
- LG APHWC802D 80-Gallon vs Midea Water Heater 80-Gallon (CAN3-RSJ-15/300RDVN3-L4)
- LG APHWC802D 80-Gallon vs Rinnai REHP80 80-Gallon
- Midea Water Heater 65-Gallon (CAN3-RSJ-15/250RDVN3-L4) vs Navien NWP500 65-Gallon
- Midea Water Heater 80-Gallon (CAN3-RSJ-15/300RDVN3-L4) vs Rinnai REHP80 80-Gallon
- AMERICAN STANDARD WATER HEATERS Heat Pump Water Heater 80-Gallon vs Bradford White RE2HP80-1NCTT 80-Gallon
- Bradford White RE2HP80-1NCTT 80-Gallon vs Rheem Heat Pump 80-Gallon (PROPH80 T2 RH375-30)
- Bradford White RE2HP80-1NCTT 80-Gallon vs Rheem Heat Pump 80-Gallon (PROPH80 T2 RH400-30)
- AMERICAN STANDARD WATER HEATERS Heat Pump Water Heater 80-Gallon vs Noritz ME80HPT-CN 80-Gallon
- Noritz ME80HPT-CN 80-Gallon vs Rheem Heat Pump 80-Gallon (PROPH80 T2 RH375-30)
- Noritz ME80HPT-CN 80-Gallon vs Rheem Heat Pump 80-Gallon (PROPH80 T2 RH400-30)
- Navien NWP500 80-Gallon vs Noritz ME80HPT-CN 80-Gallon
- A. O. Smith Heat Pump 65-Gallon (CAHP-66 2) vs Bradford White RE2HP65-1NCTT 65-Gallon
- Bradford White RE2HP65-1NCTT 65-Gallon vs LG APHWC502D 50-Gallon
- Bosch heat pump water heater 65-Gallon vs LG APHWC502D 50-Gallon
- LG APHWC502D 50-Gallon vs Midea Water Heater 65-Gallon (CAN3-RSJ-15/250RDVN3-L4)
- LG APHWC502D 50-Gallon vs Navien NWP500 65-Gallon
- Friedrich Heat Pump 65-Gallon (PROH65 T2 FD400-30) vs LG APHWC501M 50-Gallon
- GE Profile Heat Pump 50-Gallon (PH50S10BNY01) vs LG APHWC501M 50-Gallon
- LG APHWC501M 50-Gallon vs Rheem Heat Pump 65-Gallon (PROPH65 T2 RH375-30)
- AMERICAN STANDARD WATER HEATERS Heat Pump Water Heater 40-Gallon (ASHPWH-50) vs Bosch Water heater 50-Gallon
- AMERICAN STANDARD WATER HEATERS Heat Pump Water Heater 40-Gallon (ASHPWH-50) vs Friedrich Heat Pump 40-Gallon (PROH50 T2 FD400-30)
- Bradford White RE2HP80-1NCTT 80-Gallon vs Noritz ME80HPT-CN 80-Gallon
- AMERICAN STANDARD WATER HEATERS Heat Pump Water Heater 80-Gallon vs Navien NWP500 80-Gallon
- Navien NWP500 80-Gallon vs Rheem Heat Pump 80-Gallon (PROPH80 T2 RH375-30)
- Navien NWP500 80-Gallon vs Rheem Heat Pump 80-Gallon (PROPH80 T2 RH400-30)
- A. O. Smith Heat Pump 65-Gallon (CAHP-66 2) vs Navien NWP500 80-Gallon
- A. O. Smith Heat Pump 65-Gallon (CAHP-66 2) vs LG APHWC502D 50-Gallon
Gas tankless water heaters
- A. O. Smith ACTH-199M-(N,P) 1 vs Bradford White RTGR199N1
- A. O. Smith ACTH-199M-(N,P) 1 vs Friedrich FDTGH-S11I
- A. O. Smith ACTH-199M-(N,P) 1 vs Navien NPE-240S2
- A. O. Smith ACTH-199M-(N,P) 1 vs Rinnai CX199I REU-NB3237FFC-US
- A. O. Smith ACTH-199M-(N,P) 1 vs Takagi T-H3-OS-N 1
- A. O. Smith ACTH-199M-(N,P) 1 vs Takagi T-H3-OS-N 1 (TK-540X3-NEH 1)
- A. O. Smith ACTH-199M-(N,P) 1 vs Takagi T-H3-OS-N 1 (TK-540X3-PEH 1-1)
- A. O. Smith ATHR-180M 1 vs Navien NPE-210S2
- A. O. Smith ATHR-180M 1 vs Noritz EZ98DV (GQ-C2861WX-FF-1 US)
- A. O. Smith ATHR-180M 1 vs Rinnai RX180I REU-NB2934FF-US
- Bosch Greentherm (T9800 SE 160) vs Friedrich FDTGH-S84I
- Bosch Greentherm (T9800 SE 160) vs Rheem ECOHS160IN
- Bosch Greentherm (T9800 SE 160) vs Rheem ECOHS160IP
- Bosch Greentherm (T9800 SE 160) vs Rinnai CX160I REU-NB2530FFC-US
- Bradford White RTGR199N1 vs Friedrich FDTGH-S11I
- Bradford White RTGR199N1 vs Navien NPE-240S2
- Bradford White RTGR199N1 vs Rinnai CX199I REU-NB3237FFC-US
- Bradford White RTGR199N1 vs Takagi T-H3-OS-N 1
- Bradford White RTGR199N1 vs Takagi T-H3-OS-N 1 (TK-540X3-NEH 1)
- Bradford White RTGR199N1 vs Takagi T-H3-OS-N 1 (TK-540X3-PEH 1-1)
- Friedrich FDTGH-S10I vs Midea JSG48-29PCH-LP
- Friedrich FDTGH-S10I vs Rheem ECOHS180IN
- Friedrich FDTGH-S11I vs Navien NPE-240S2
- Friedrich FDTGH-S11I vs Rinnai CX199I REU-NB3237FFC-US
- Friedrich FDTGH-S11I vs Takagi T-H3-OS-N 1
- Friedrich FDTGH-S11I vs Takagi T-H3-OS-N 1 (TK-540X3-NEH 1)
- Friedrich FDTGH-S11I vs Takagi T-H3-OS-N 1 (TK-540X3-PEH 1-1)
- Friedrich FDTGH-S84I vs Rheem ECOHS160IN
- Friedrich FDTGH-S84I vs Rheem ECOHS160IP
- Friedrich FDTGH-S84I vs Rinnai CX160I REU-NB2530FFC-US
- Midea JSG40-24PCH-LP vs Navien NPE-180S2
- Midea JSG40-24PCH-NG vs Navien NPE-180S2
- Midea JSG48-29PCH-LP vs Rheem ECOHS180IN
- Navien NPE-210S2 vs Noritz EZ98DV (GQ-C2861WX-FF-1 US)
- Navien NPE-210S2 vs Rinnai RX180I REU-NB2934FF-US
- Navien NPE-240S2 vs Rinnai CX199I REU-NB3237FFC-US
- Navien NPE-240S2 vs Takagi T-H3-OS-N 1
- Navien NPE-240S2 vs Takagi T-H3-OS-N 1 (TK-540X3-NEH 1)
- Navien NPE-240S2 vs Takagi T-H3-OS-N 1 (TK-540X3-PEH 1-1)
- Noritz EZ98DV (GQ-C2861WX-FF-1 US) vs Rinnai RX180I REU-NB2934FF-US
Gas storage water heaters
- Friedrich 12PROG 40-50P FD HE EC3 40-Gallon vs Rheem PROP G40-50-CN HE 40-Gallon
- Friedrich 12PROG 40-50U FD HE EC3 40-Gallon vs Rheem PROP G40-50-CN HE 40-Gallon
- Friedrich Gas Storage 50-Gallon (12PROG 50-100P FD HE EC3) vs Rheem Gas Storage 50-Gallon (PROP G50-100-CN HE EC3)
- A. O. Smith GC6-PS4050-V 1 40-Gallon vs Friedrich 12PROG 40-50P FD HE EC3 40-Gallon
- A. O. Smith GC6-PS4050-V 1 40-Gallon vs Friedrich 12PROG 40-50U FD HE EC3 40-Gallon
- A. O. Smith GC6-PS4050-V 1 40-Gallon vs Rheem PROP G40-50-CN HE 40-Gallon
- A. O. Smith GPCC-40L 1 40-Gallon vs Friedrich 12PROG 40-50P FD HE EC3 40-Gallon
- A. O. Smith GPCC-40L 1 40-Gallon vs Friedrich 12PROG 40-50U FD HE EC3 40-Gallon
- A. O. Smith GPCC-40L 1 40-Gallon vs Rheem PROP G40-50-CN HE 40-Gallon
- Rheem Gas Storage 50-Gallon (PROP G50-76-CN HE EC3) vs State GP6-75-TPDT 3 80-Gallon
- A. O. Smith GC6-PS5065-V 1 50-Gallon vs State GP6-75-TPDT 3 80-Gallon
- American VG6250T100-V 3 50-Gallon vs Friedrich 12PROG 40-50P FD HE EC3 40-Gallon
- American VG6250T100-V 3 50-Gallon vs Friedrich 12PROG 40-50U FD HE EC3 40-Gallon
- American VG6250T100-V 3 50-Gallon vs Rheem PROP G40-50-CN HE 40-Gallon